"Do you respect the participants of the study mentioned in this article? Why or why not? Do you agree that these people are brave because they refuse to give in to the pressure that is surrounding them?"
MAKE SURE TO INCLUDE ELEMENTS OF THE ARTICLE IN YOUR COMMENT SO THAT I WILL KNOW THAT YOU READ IT!!
Report: Millions Of Courageous Americans Overcoming Media Pressure To Be Thin
AUSTIN—According to a groundbreaking report released this week by researchers at the University of Texas, tens of millions of citizens across the United States are bravely resisting the relentless pressure from the media to be thin and active.
The 80-page report confirmed that Americans are inundated with images of slender individuals in commercials, films, television shows, print advertisements, billboards, internet ads, and product packaging every day, yet noted that as many as 190 million citizens are “courageously refusing to conform” to these media ideals of physical fitness and leanness and are instead embracing the bodies they have.
“Given the media’s clear preference for thin physiques, we expected most Americans would be actively seeking to emulate such body types, but we found that nearly 7 in 10 American adults possess the inner courage and determination to overcome the constant pressure to maintain a trim figure,” said behavioral psychologist and the report’s co-author Olivia Trumbull, noting that these Americans boldly ignored, on average, 10 to 14 images of in-shape individuals every minute of the day. “This level of resolve is astonishing, considering that the media is saturated with models, actors, athletes, and pop stars who are no bigger than a women’s size 4 or a men’s large. However, if you look around any American town or city, you’ll find incredibly brave women who are size 18, size 20, even size 24, as well as brave men who routinely wear XXXL clothing. That’s a testament to American willpower.”
“These are regular people who, all day long, are bombarded with unrelenting messages touting the desirability of being athletic or even moderately healthy, and their response is to loudly proclaim, ‘No, that’s not who I am,’” Trumbull added. “That’s the definition of courage.”
The report emphasized the demographic’s “incredible strength of character,” noting that such individuals were able to look past the uniformly thin celebrities that popular culture has provided for them, as well as the healthful lifestyles these media figures purvey. Indeed, the report found that, rather than give in to the constant emphasis on a lean, shapely physique, the brave segment of the U.S. population consistently and valiantly avoided nutritious foods, reasonable portion sizes, and any exercise whatsoever.
Moreover, the study found evidence that most Americans were courageously becoming heavier and significantly more sedentary in proud defiance of the media messages that are broadcast at them throughout the day.
“What’s most intriguing about our findings is that these stirring individuals who are standing up against Hollywood studios and Madison Avenue advertisers are not people who have isolated themselves from popular culture; rather, these are people who watch television and are on their computers all the time,” said the study’s co-author, Dr. Wesley Steigman. “It appears that no matter how much the media glamorizes moving around, eating only three meals a day, or just generally treating one’s body with respect and concern for one’s future well-being, most Americans staunchly refuse to let these messages affect them. The fortitude and strength it must take to do this is truly inspiring.”
Although researchers identified such heroic members of society in every region of the country, they noted that the greatest levels of courage were found in low-income communities, particularly in the South and Midwest. Additionally, the report also drew attention to the “immense levels of bravery” among the nation’s children, many of whom were found to be rebelling against thin, healthy media stereotypes by embracing extremely large body types as early as two years of age.
While focusing mainly on body image, the report also briefly highlighted Americans’ remarkable bravery at withstanding other forms of media pressure, noting that millions of citizens were boldly rejecting messages to be educated, hardworking, and to maintain basic hygiene as well.
“When I look around and see thin, healthy people on every magazine cover and TV screen, it’s hard not to think that maybe I should alter my appearance to try to be more like them,” said research participant and Type 2 diabetic Henry Dobbs of Memphis, TN. “It’s a struggle each day when I see those people who look nothing like me and then I see myself in the mirror. But then I tell myself that I will not be bullied by the media or anyone else.”
“I’m not going to change my lifestyle just to live up to some media ideal of being an appropriate weight for my height or having a healthy body,” Dobbs added, pausing a moment to catch his breath. “And by setting a strong example, I hope I’m passing that same message down to my kids.”
In addition to confirming that Americans were currently standing up in record numbers against media pressure to be thin, the report concluded by noting that, according to all projections, the percentage of such heroic individuals is expected to only continue climbing sharply for the foreseeable future.
"Report: Millions Of Courageous Americans Overcoming Media Pressure To Be Thin | The Onion - America's Finest News Source." The Onion - America's Finest News Source. N.p., n.d. Web. 3 Sept. 2013. .
Ooh, body image, way to hit the heart, pop culture. Optimal body weight? What does this mean exactly? That you have to be a CERTAIN weight to fit in the social norm? I totally respect Henry Dobbs, and i understand his choice, and I personally think he is in fact, very courageous and awesome for standing up for what he believes in. But it is his health, and he can go down swinging or he could concur with the norm.
ReplyDeleteAndrea Rosario
Abby Nelson- I do respect these people that are showing others that they won't give in to all of the pressure. I think its good that they don't care what other people think and are trying to be who they are. In the article when it says that they don't want to be like the people on TV and magazines, I think they are very brave for taking a stand. I am very glad that they didn't give into the pressure and keep living their life the how they want. A life with out anyone influencing their choices.
ReplyDeleteNot every one in the world can be as asking as a a stick. Some people may not exercise and some may just eat. With magazines at every corner with size 0 models on the covering can anyone feel insecure and uncomfortable with their body. I do respect them and I think they are curageous because its their body and their life. They choose wether or not they want to be thin or not exercise. Just because someone else has a perfect figure doesn't mean you have to.
ReplyDeleteApril McCool
Austin levins
ReplyDeleteI respect thes people just as I respect every one, but there is nothing brave about what they are doing they arent doing this out of protest. Most of them want to look good but can't do it. They say it is out of protest but that is rediculous the reason they don't change there size is because they either can't or don't want to Putin the effort. It is there choice to look the way they want. The media does put to much emphasis on shape but they are not brave because they are not fighting it. This is just an excuse for people who are out of shape. There is nothing brave about it.
taryn dockery
ReplyDeleteI think that its really ignorant of Americans to put people to shame about their appearance. everyone is not a super skinny size four or below. healthy food is actually really expensive, so im not really surprised that the report said that low income families were a big part of those who were somewhat overweight. I think that its awesome that 7 out of 10 americans were willing to stand up to those people that try to dictate what everyone should weigh. lets make it 10 out of 10. I think its awful to make people feel bad just because they are overweight. everyone is beautiful in their own way!
I do no respect the participants of this study because they are being ignorant. Its one thing not to conform to society, and another just to disregard your state of health to be "different". They are brave not to listen to society, but not brave in how they are not listening just to prove a point.
ReplyDelete~Laura Coats
Marie Doyle
ReplyDeleteFirst of all kudos on using the Onion. That was a very amusing article. Although it is not actually serious, the article brings up some interesting points. For example, the part where they mention the fact that people refuse to try and take better care of their bodies, is actually very true. Some people do not try to be healthier at all. But, recently I was talking with my dad and I learned the mental difficulties of losing weight. Our bodies are not used to the modern problem of too much food, and have very deeply ingrained mental barriers, so it can try and keep the weight. So people might be trying to improve their health, but can't. I think sometimes people just have a larger body type and therefore are brave for embracing their body and not trying to be stick skinny.
Jordan Chestnut~ I think that these people are very brave for doing this, standing up to the media is not an easy thing especially when it comes to weight. These people are comfortable in their own skin, which is great for them and they shouldn't change at all.
ReplyDeleteI respect the participants of the study mentioned in the article because we shouldn't conform to look a certain way. In the article people are called brave for not changing how they look, I don't know that I would say people are brave because they refuse to give in to pressure surrounding them because everyone goes through a point in their life where they face pressure. So if they are brave for that we all should be named brave and the word has less meaning to someone awarded on bravery in battle for example. In the research, Henry Dobbs, with type 2 diabetics doesn't conform to images on magazines or public because he isn't going to change for the 'ideal' appropriate weight for his height. With this being said there has been a 'ideal' weight made for people in which people think you should be. Which makes no sense whatsoever because people are different, different body shapes,different genetic dispositions, such as hypothyroidism. People are different so why are we trying to be alike.
ReplyDeleteGabby Traywick 1st period
In some aspects, I do repect the participants of the article. In our society today, the media seems to be trying to warp our ideas of beauty.Its like no one cares about the whats on the inside anymore, just the outside. Girls are striving to be stick thin, and sadly sometimes this results in an eating disorder. However, I do think people should try to be as healthy as they can possibly be. Maintaining physical activity is good for you.
ReplyDelete-Emily Free
Taylor Burge
ReplyDeleteThere is no mention in this article of actual participants in a research study. The article references that millions of Americans are obese. I respect all people but I do not believe thta they are purposefully resisting media temptation to be thin. The writers have chosen to state that America as a whole is obese,but have used a tongue-in-cheek style to do so. I do not believe they are being brave in choosing to be overweight. I believe that they are being like most Americans and taking the eaiser way of life where they do not exercise and choose healthier meals and portions.
mills harrison
ReplyDeleteI think that people should take the advice from the media and strive to get in to shape. usually bigger people have more heart and health problems and don't live as long as fit and cut people. One reason why we have so may overweight people now is because the portion size for say the king size candy bars and the 16 ounce soft drinks. Well back in the 40's the drinks came in little glass bottles and the candy was small to. So I think we should cut down on portions and get into shape.
Jane Frances Armour
ReplyDeleteI do not respect the participants of the study mentioned in this article.In this article Henry Dobbs does not want his children to give into the medias idea of a healthy body. I understand that the participants do not desire to be very skinny but they need to treat their own body with respect and give it the proper nutrition it needs. These people are brave because they are doing the opposite of what the world expects of them and going against this perfect body image that the media gives us.
Jordan Tatum
ReplyDeleteThis article makes a point. Some people in our country don't see what's wrong with being a size 22 instead of a 2, which there is nothing wrong with that. But then again too many people say that being overweight is wrong, which is true to a degree but if the person is happy leave them be, don't put them down because of their weight. But also there is a fine line between overweight and obese. The article is saying that people are ignoring the commercials and ads about weight loss because they are happy, so as long as the person is happy there should be nothing wrong with being a larger size.
I respect the participants in this study because they have revealed the actual courage of people who are not thin. I agree that these people are brave because they have not been pressured to lose weight, nor become fit. These people will not let the media pressure them to become different, which shows bravery. Just because celebrities are thin doesn't mean people who are not the thin should become thin. The article stated,”…the demographic’s “incredible strength of character,” noting that such individuals were able to look past the uniformly thin celebrities that popular culture has provided for them, as well as the healthful lifestyles these media figures purvey." These people are indeed brave not to be pressured to change themselves because of the media.
ReplyDeleteNikhil Singh
Casey Page
ReplyDeleteI believe that people should be able to choose what they would like their appearance to look like, but... I think it would make our country look a lot better than it does now. cough* Carson.... jk coach. but in all seriousness I think that people should really slow down on their eating and speed up on their exercising.
John Foster~
ReplyDeleteI believe if people refuse to take care of their body it should be their own fault. They should have to make up for it on their own time if the wish to. Kids should be encouraged to eat healthy regardless though. If we were to lower taxes on healthy food we might help out the obese lower class. Junk food is cheep. Until healthy food is to weight will always be a problem in a "first world" society.
As for the questions, the "participants" are not what you call good examples if they are truly happy with being un-healthy. I would much rather everyone lead a healthy life and not a wasted one, but I do not have the power to take away their rights to eat.(Yet...)
Jake Presley
ReplyDeleteI agree that all people should be respected and accepted. I disagree with the idea that it is a strength of character and brave to rebel against the thin and fit portrayed in the media. In my opinion, it is not an issue of being pencil thin vs. overweight but just being healthy. It is not brave to choose an unhealthy lifestyle. I noticed in the article that Dobbs paused to catch his breath. Maybe, being overweight is affecting his heart, lungs and overall health. I do not think that is a very positive example to pass down to his kids.
I respect these people in the sense that they are brave enough to walk around being that much bigger then others and not care. What I don't respect is that they had to go prove it by taking part in a research project.
ReplyDeleteKatie Kinder
I believe that it is a wonderful thing that overweight and unhealthy people are not becoming upset or overreacting about the difference in the medias idea of an ideal body and their body, however I do not believe that their not caring enough about their health to even try to lead a healthier lifestyle is not bold, brave, heroic, or courageous. I believe that it is simply laziness which I completely understand but find in no way heroic. I believe that it is great that Henry Dobbs does not want to let peoples expectations control him because its his life but at the same time I disagree about his belief that it would be good for his children to be unhealthy as this could shorten their lifespan and subtract from their quality of life due to chronic health conditions.
ReplyDeleteJohn McDonough
I think that it is a wonderful thing that overweight and unhealthy people are not and over reacting and becoming upset because of the way people are portrayed in the media. It is their life after all and the media shouldn’t be able to control people. However I would not consider them to be brave, bold, courageous, or heroic or heroic because of their indifference to media pressure. I would consider their unwillingness to change be laziness. I do not think this is a very horrible thing either though because I understand that it would take more effort to change than it would not to. I view Henry Dobb’s statement “I’m not going to change my lifestyle just to live up to some media ideal of being an appropriate weight for my height or having a healthy body,” as a testament to his own stubborn laziness and I find the fact the he wants his children to be stubborn lazy and unhealthy to be appalling, morbid, and wrong. On another subject I disagree with another person’s idea for solving America’s obesity problem. I think that changing portion sizes would have little or no effect because without self-control and determination compulsive eaters and inactive people will not get any healthier.
ReplyDeleteJohn McDonough